On Thursday, during a congressional hearing with BP CEO Tony Hayward
, Representative Joe Barton, a Republican of Texas, apologized personally to Hayward for the behavior of the Obama administration
the day before. Obama had secured a $20 billion compensation account
from BP to offset damages caused by the Gulf oil spill, and it was this
that Barton repeatedly apologized for, calling it "a shakedown" and "a
tragedy of the first proportion." Barton's remarks have occasioned a
complex set of responses from the right
, but a fair number of onlookers
are simply apoplectic. (UPDATE: Barton has since apologized for his
comments; see the bottom of this post.)
- What Barton Said Here's the transcript, as taken from this video.
speaking now totally for myself. I'm not speaking for the Republican
Party, I'm not speaking for anybody in the House of Representatives but
myself. But I'm ashamed of what happened in the White House yesterday.
I think it is a tragedy of the first proportion that a private
corporation could be subjected to what I would characterize as a
shakedown--in this case, a $20 billion shakedown--with the attorney
general of the United States, who is legitimately conducting a criminal
investigation, and has every right to do so to protect the interests of
the American people, participating in what amounts to a $20 billion
slush fund that's unprecedented in our nation's history, that's got no
legal standing, and which sets, I think, a terrible precedent for the
future ... There is no question that BP is liable for the damages. But
we have a due process system where we go through hearings, in some
cases court cases, litigation, and determine what those damages are and
when those damages should be paid. So I'm only speaking for myself, I'm
not speaking for anybody else, but I apologize. I do not want to live
in a country where any time a citizen or a corporation does something
that is legitimately wrong, he's subjected to some sort of political
pressure that is again, in my words, amounts to a shakedown. So I
- 'Shameful' Press Secretary Robert Gibbs hit back with what Politico's Ben Smith calls "a very fast, campaigny statement." Here's the text of Gibbs's response:
is shameful is that Joe Barton seems to have more concern for big
corporations that caused this disaster than the fishermen, small
business owners and communities whose lives have been devastated by the
destruction. Congressman Barton may think that a fund to compensate
these Americans is a ‘tragedy’, but most Americans know that the real
tragedy is what the men and women of the Gulf Coast are going through
right now. Members from both parties should repudiate his comments.
- Whoops! The Washington Monthly's Steve Benen
sums up the feelings of many: Barton's remarks will prove invaluable to
the Democrats come election season. "In an election context, this has
the potential to be incredibly toxic. Barton's public apology to BP
will be part of about a zillion campaign ads over the next several
months, and Republicans have made a huge strategic error positioning
themselves as the Party of BP."
- Could Be a Game-Changer, agrees
Greg Sargent at The Washington Post. "Every now and then a gaffe comes
along that really cuts through the noise and perfectly crystallizes the
argument one side is trying to make, driving the debate with a whole
new level of velocity and momentum. Barton's apology, with its
extraordinary public display of solicitiousness and even pity towards
the despised BP, even as the country is suffering wrenching losses from
a major disaster of BP's making, is one of those moments."
- This Goes Way Beyond Barton, points out Josh Marshall
at Talking Points Memo. "What actually has me curious is when this gets
back around to the House Republican Study Committee, which is
essentially the right-wing or Movement conservative caucus within the
House GOP, and a very big deal. Everybody's reacting to Barton's
statement. But the HRS put out a pretty much identical statement
yesterday about the Escrow account and President Obama yesterday. And
more than a hundred members of the House Republican caucus belong to
that group. That makes it much more of a Republican position than what
- Barton's Kind of a Jerk, declares Alex Pareene
at Salon. "Joe Barton does not want to live in a world where when
corporations do bad things, they are forced to suffer consequences ...
Barton has received more than $1.5 million from the oil industry. He's
received more than $100,000 from oil and gas since last year. He does
not believe in global warming and when he was previously chairman of
the committee he used his post to harass climate scientists. He is dumb
and mean ... And he'll be the most powerful member of the House on all
energy and climate issues should the Republicans take back the House."
- Joe Biden's Not Happy Here are some of the phrases Vice President Biden
used to describe Barton's statements (after much good-natured cajoling
from reporters). "Incredibly insensitive, incredibly out of touch...
outrageous... pretty astounding." Biden also marveled at Barton's
characterization of the White House-BP agreement as a "shakedown":
"It's insisting on responsible conduct, and a responsible response to
something they caused."
- What Barton Said a Few Hours Later The New York Times reports
on Barton's mid-day clarification: "I want the record to be absolutely
clear that I believe BP is responsible for this accident, should be
held responsible and should in every way possible make good on the
consequences that have resulted from this accident. If anything I’ve
said this morning was misconstrued from that I want to apologize for
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
aeichler at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.